• Local Knowledge
  • Tenancy Experience
  • Qualified Managers
  • Thorough Inspections
  • Trusted Contractors
  • Quality Agreements


Donna Matthes is a highly regarded Property Manager at INSPECT TENANCY on Waiheke Island, Auckland. With extensive local knowledge and property management expertise, Donna provides a high-quality service to landlords, property owners, and tenants alike.

Donna Matthes

Director/ Property Manager

Level 4 NZQA Residential Property Management


Welcome to Inspect Tenancy – Professional Property Services on Waiheke Island


"Hi, I’m Donna Matthes, and I am proud to offer bespoke casual services and full property management options tailored for landlords and property owners right here on beautiful Waiheke Island.


As someone born and raised on Waiheke Island, I am proud to call this special place home and even prouder to serve its community. Since 2012, I have built my career in property management, beginning with a portfolio of holiday homes and progressing into long-term residential tenancies. Through this journey, I have developed the knowledge, experience, and practical skills needed to manage properties effectively and professionally.


My experience includes a strong working knowledge of the Residential Tenancies Act, a reliable network of trusted local contractors, and the ability to identify maintenance issues early and resolve them proactively.

I also hold a Level 4 NZQA Residential Property Management qualification, so landlords can rest assured that I am following the correct guidelines with their tenancies, minimising any potential tenancy risks.


Being local means I not only know the island, but I also understand the people, the market, and the lifestyle. That is what sets Inspect Tenancy apart.


Inspect Tenancy gives you peace of mind and more time to enjoy life. Whether you need support with a one-off inspection or full management, I am here to make property ownership simple and stress-free.


I look forward to discussing your rental options with you."


Donna Matthes

What our clients say...

Make sure the title suits the content of this text.

We contacted Donna Matthes of Inspect Tenancy to manage our home rental when we went overseas for 7 months. We had prior experience with other local property managers over a period of several years, as we had spent half our time overseas, and we had some very bad experiences.


Donna was just so good from the first meeting. Professional, competent, tactful, and pleasant, with a great sense of humor, we knew we could place the care of our home in her hands while we were away.


Donna took the time and discernment in screening applicants to find a tenant for our place who was a good match for what our property had to offer. Unlike other managers who seemed to only screen to find a body who said they would pay the rent.

Donna was very detailed in her inspections of the property character and condition, and noted all pertinent details. Her comprehensive video inspections, notes and photo closeups inside and outside, really helped us, as we were overseas.


When there was work to be done, Donna coordinated that work with service people amazingly well, with tireless communication back and forth on our behalf and to keep us informed.


We recommend Donna highly to anyone, whether you are a homeowner or you are looking to find a rental. You will be well served to go with Inspect Tenancy

Lisa and Jeff (Property Owner)

Jan 2026

I can’t speak highly enough of Donna. We entrusted her to look after our near new home for years and she’s hands down the best property manager we’ve ever had let alone on Waiheke.

Donna genuinely cares and has always looked after our place like it’s her own. She’s got amazing attention to detail is amazing, is a proactive communicator, takes the initiative and is just an all round pleasure to deal with!


If you want someone who truly cares about your property, Donna’s your person.

Five stars without hesitation!

Richard (Property Owner)

Dec 2025

Donna really is the best Rental agent I have ever come across. She has the perfect balance of professional and emotional intelligence which benefits both landlords and tenant's.


She must work really hard behind the scenes yet still responds quickly and kindly to any request. She really has been a delight to deal with.


She has the best intentions for all to succeed and definitely goes the extra mile naturally and effortlessly.


She takes all the stress out of what could be a stressful situation

Gretel (Tenant)

Jun 2025

Donna is the best!


Exceptionally thorough, professional, and always quick to respond to any enquiries or issues.


She genuinely strives to achieve the best outcome for both landlords and tenants.


Overall, an outstanding experience — easily the best agency on Waiheke Island.

Jeanette (Tenant)

Jun 2025

Donna has been the best property manager! Very efficient, friendly and professional, would highly recommend to anyone!

Ramond (Tenant)

Aug 2025

Always a pleasure dealing with Inspect Tenancy. Prompt service, really easy to communicate with and a vast amount of local knowledge.


I would definitely use Donna again and wouldn't hesitate to recommend. thankyou!

Brad (Business Owner)

Dec 2025

I highly recommend Inspect Tenancy.


Donna was very thorough and professional, offering great advice and prompt communication. Everything went so smoothly.

Lisa (Property Owner)

Aug 2024

We have engaged Donna for on multiple occasions for one off letting of properties and rental appraisals on Waiheke. Donna works fast and has great communication. Highly recommend to all.

Jonathon (Property Owner)

Apr 2024

We recently had the pleasure of working with Donna, from Inspect Tenancy, for a rental appraisal. The process was easy from start to finish.


Donna is professional, knowledgeable and efficient. Not only did she provide a comprehensive rental appraisal, but she offered valuable insights and suggestions about how to enhance the property's appeal.


Highly recommend this service.

Tanique (Property Owner)

Nov 2023